Niles's stories and the songs themselves flesh out the line drawings of preservationist recordings.
~Green Man Review
The histories accompanying each ballad in this work are delightful histories, anecdotes and vignettes, interesting in and of themselves.
~Kentucky Libraries
Niles has really given us two books in one: a superior 'Child-ballad' songster, [and] a series of descriptions, anecdotes, and folksay from informants.... For more than fifty years he has made a traditional culture seem as beautiful as his own devoted and dignified spirit.
~New York Herald-Tribune
His most ambitious effort in a long and rich career.
~New York Times
A treasure trove for musicians, living history enthusiasts, and many other readers.
~Reviewers Consortium
His comments are as valuable as the songs are beautiful.... A marvelous book.
~Washington Post
[...] Pen provides us with, hands down, the ablest guide to understanding an artist who might otherwise be an enigma. It is in that capacity that his book most excels.
~Journal of Folklore Research